One would think that government entities voting to divert taxpayer dollars to “economic development” projects would want to get the biggest bang for their buck.
Yes, one would think.
But the creation of a so-called Transit Revitalization Investment District (TRID) — that incudes downtown Pittsburgh, the Strip District and parts of the North Shore — mandates that developers getting TRID dollars hire union labor.
The measure would allow 75 percent of new tax revenue from developments to be diverted for other projects for 20 years. The TRID itself would be in effect for 40 years. Existing tax revenues would not be diverted.
But never mind that the union labor codicil would automatically inflate the cost of any development, as a Heritage Foundation study concluded, in general, and with myriad other negative, if not unintended, consequences.
Here are a few snippets detailing the deleterious effects of government mandating the use of union labor:
“Unions simply do not provide the economic benefits that their supporters claim they provide. They are labor cartels, intentionally reducing the number of jobs to drive up wages for their members.
“In competitive markets, unions cannot cartelize labor and raise wages. Companies with higher labor costs go out of business. Consequently, unions do not raise wages in many newly organized companies. Unions can raise wages only at companies that have competitive advantages that permit them to pay higher wages, such as successful R&D projects or long-lasting capital investments.
“On balance, unionizing raises wages [up to] 10 percent, but these wage increases come at a steep economic cost. They cut into profits and reduce the returns on investments. Businesses respond predictably by investing significantly less in capital and R&D projects.
“Unions have the same effect on business investment as does a 33 percentage point corporate income tax increase.
“Less investment makes unionized companies less competitive, and they gradually shrink. Combined with the intentional efforts of a labor cartel to restrict labor, unions cut jobs.
“Unionized firms are no more likely than non-union firms to go out of business — unions make concessions to avoid bankruptcy — but jobs grow at a 4 percent slower rate at unionized businesses than at other companies.
“Over time, unions destroy jobs in the companies they organize. In manufacturing, three-quarters of all union jobs have disappeared over the past three decades, while the number of non-union jobs has increased.”
And finally, from The Heritage Foundation analysis of union labor’s effects:
“No economic theory posits that cartels improve economic efficiency. Nor has reality ever shown them to do so. Union cartels retard economic growth … .”
Pittsburgh City Council approved the TRID in July. Allegheny County Council and the Pittsburgh Public Schools board have yet to take up the proposal. The latter two governing bodies would be wise to think thrice about following suit.
And, ironically, organized labor officials pushing for this TRID and other similar programs appear quite eager to be the agents of their own demise, given The Heritage Foundation assessment of the real effects of the labor cartels.
How rich is that? And it’s par for the union course.
Colin McNickle is communications and marketing director at the Allegheny Institute for Public Policy (www.alleghenyinstitute.org).