On this, the first anniversary of Pittsburgh International Airport’s (PIT) new Midfield Terminal, from former US Airways corporate spokesman David Castelveter:
“A renovation was needed, [but] was it worth the cost of $1.7 billion? I seriously doubt it,” he told the Post-Gazette, reminding that the project’s bill ballooned 54.5 percent from the original $1.1 billion estimate.
Yet, Allegheny County Airport Authority CEO Christina Cassotis continues to insist that “It was not actually cheaper to fix [up the old Landside Terminal] than to do this.”
The P-G dutifully notes, however, that “the Airport Authority has yet to provide figures to support her claim.”
As it also has not, we add, provided any figures to support its oft-repeated claim that using taxpayer dollars to subsidize foreign flights to PIT has resulted in any kind of economic boon to Greater Pittsburgh.
It’s more likely that the flights are an export engine – for U.S. dollars.
The Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership (PDP) — while insisting that demand for Downtown living is strong – laments to the Post-Gazette that there is, in general, a $162,000 per apartment difference between development cost and what rental income can support.
Have we got a business deal for you, eh?
Cate Irvin, senior director of economic development at the PDP, told the P-G that “even with strong demand … moving projects forward requires creative financing, strategic partnerships and new approaches.”
Allow us to translate: A hefty bolus of taxpayer dollars, an even heftier bolus of taxpayer dollars and “new approaches” to turn taxpayers upside down and shake even more taxpayer dollars out of their pockets.
Oh, by gosh, by golly, it’s a trifecta of public purpose perversion.
Irvin notes that the construction cost for 356 apartments in five Downtown office to residential conversion projects was nearly $146 million — an average of about $410,000 per unit.
But she tells the P-G that Golden Triangle rents are around $2,240 per month, which “supports an estimated value of $248,000,” Irvin said, leaving that $162,000 financing gap.
Gee, what’s the marketplace saying, class? That demand is not high enough to make these conversions economically feasible and that lenders deem them too risky to further back.
For the umpteenth time, taxpayers have no business assuming the bill for developers’ unwise, tarpit choices. And developers have no business turning taxpayers into involuntary venture capitalists and throwing them into those proverbial tarpits.
And you don’t need a business degree from The Wharton School to understand the nod-nod, wink-wink ripoffs that have been going on for far too long.
Colin McNickle is communications and marketing director at the Allegheny Institute for Public Policy (cmcnickle@alleghenyinstitute.org).