Newly re-elected Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro and likely incoming Senate President Pro Tempore Jay Costa want to make life in the Keystone State less affordable by raising food prices, increasing rents and killing jobs.
How do we know this? They’ve said so. No, not directly. But they’ve ramped up their campaign to raise the commonwealth’s minimum wage, from $7.25 an hour to $15. That’s a 106.9 percent increase.
Incredibly, and incomprehensibly given the facts, Costa, the Pittsburgh Democrat, noted in a September news release, that “Raising the minimum wage is a key pillar” in Senate Democrats’ “action plan … to … reduce costs for Pennsylvanians.”
But as Michael Saltsman, executive director of the Employment Policies Institute, detailed in a Thursday Wall Street Journal commentary:
“Dozens of states and cities have raised their minimum wages. These local mandates range from $8.75 in West Virginia to nearly three times the federal standard in Seattle. Rather than make life more affordable, these interventions make it less so.
“A study published in the Journal of Economic Surveys found that a 10 percent increase in the minimum wage causes food-price increases up to 4 percent. These price hikes can be felt directly (through the increased cost of a meal out) or indirectly, when accumulated costs across sectors lead to unexpected consequences.
“A report in the Journal of Urban Economics found that a 10 percent increase in minimum wage was associated with up to a 7.3 percent increase in rent, erasing some of the short-term benefit from a wage boost. In a 2026 survey of U.S. labor economists, 80 percent said a $20 federal mandate would broadly raise the cost of living.
As Saltsman further notes, it’s “a vicious circle”:
“Lawmakers raise the minimum wage, responding to concerns about rising costs; then the higher minimum wage causes costs to rise further, triggering more calls to ‘raise the wage.’”
Intellectual vapidity never had a better sponsor.
And Saltsman reminds that higher prices aren’t the only consequence. “When businesses can’t raise customer prices high enough to offset rising costs, they’re forced to cut back on jobs.”
He cites a study in the Journal of Labor Economics that found “minimum wage hikes between 2011 and 2019 reduced the employment rate for young workers by more than 2.5 percentage points—which translates to nearly a quarter million jobs.”
Back to Gov. Shapiro. One of his oft-repeated arguments for more than doubling the minimum wage is that the supposed masses earning only $7.25 an hour can’t live on such a wage.
But citing U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics data, Saltsman reminds that only about 0.1 percent of the hourly workforce is paid $7.25.
Shapiro also has repeatedly beaten the drum that Pennsylvania cannot compete with surrounding states that have raised their wage floor; the Keystone State is losing workers to those states, he more than implies.
But that’s simply false, as Allegheny Institute Research Associate Alex Sodini noted (in Policy Brief Vol. 26, No. 19):
“The inability to attract and retain residents and underwhelming economic performance suggests Pennsylvania and most of its neighbors are already highly uncompetitive – even though a majority boast minimum wages at or above $15 per hour.
“As such, there’s little evidence to support the idea that Pennsylvania must increase its minimum wage to attract residents or stay economically competitive with surrounding states,” Sodini concluded.
And just because the Messrs. Shapiro and Costa of the minimum-wage debate keep repeating their Pinocchios doesn’t make them true.
Colin McNickle is communications and marketing director at the Allegheny Institute for Public Policy(cmcnickle@alleghenyinstitute.org).