Casino revenues continue to climb

Summary: When the total gaming revenues for October were released, the news headlines proclaimed a record-breaking month with more $425 million generated.  With the previous record being set just a few months earlier (July had $423.6 million in revenues), 2021 is on pace to be a record-setting year.  But that may have more to do with increasing gaming options and three new mini-casinos.

_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Past Policy Briefs have documented the progress of gaming in the commonwealth since legislation was passed in 2004.  The legislation guaranteed a slot license to all horse-racing tracks with a few stand-alone casinos, including one in the City of Pittsburgh.  In 2009, there were nine casinos in operation, including The Rivers in Pittsburgh, and slot machine gross terminal revenues (GTR) reached $1.96 billion. 

Slot machines

Statewide slot machine GTR topped out at $2.47 billion in 2012 when there were only 11 casinos in operation.  The first resort casino (Valley Forge) opened in early 2012 and the second (Nemacolin) opened in 2013.  From 2013 through 2019 statewide GTR averaged $2.36 billion.  During the 2020 pandemic year statewide GTR fell to $1.36 billion.  It has rebounded thus far in 2021 to hit $1.91 billion through October and is on pace to reach $2.29 billion—about 3 percent shy of 2019’s total. 

It is important to realize that the number of slot machines in operation has been steadily increasing over the years.  In 2009 the monthly average was 21,450 slot machines across the nine casinos in operation. By 2019 the monthly average came in at 24,700—a 15 percent increase.  Due to social distancing in the pandemic, the number of machines in operation has fallen to about 23,000 in 2021.  It is also important to note that the number of casinos has also increased to 15 as three new mini-casinos were opened in 2020-21. 

The per machine GTR did not change much, rising from $7,750 in 2009 to $7,968 in 2019—an increase of only 3 percent.  It has picked up a bit in 2021, rising to $8,375, in large part due to higher-than-normal play in March through May (a per machine average of $9,700) as people began returning to casinos after a long absence.  The average per machine play in August through October was more in line with the 2019 figure ($7,900).   

This is important because slot machine revenues were touted as the reason for legalizing gaming in Pennsylvania—GTR are taxed at rate of 54 percent with 34 percent going toward school property tax relief.  The remaining 20 percent is divided between economic development, the local share assessment and the racehorse development fund. 

With stagnant GTR and rising property tax bills, substantial relief from gaming is no longer possible. 

Table games

Table games were introduced in 2010, just a couple years after the debut of slot machines.  Gross revenues from table games do not go into the property tax relief fund.  They are taxed at 14 percent with 12 percent going to the state’s general fund. 

In 2011, the first full year of table games, statewide gross revenues came in around $620 million.  They grew steadily over the next few years until reaching $903.5 million in 2019.  The pandemic caused those revenues to drop to $504.3 million.  In 2021, statewide revenues have reached $758.6 million, through October, and are on pace to reach a record $910.3 million—just topping the amount in 2019. 

The number of table games available increased over the years.  In 2011 there was an average of 900 tables per month spread across 11 casinos which grew to 1,276 by 2019—an increase of 42 percent.  In 2021 it is over 1,370 tables across 15 casinos in the commonwealth.  On a per-table basis, the average in 2011 came in at $57,392 and reached a peak in 2017 at $59,737.  The 2021 average thus far is $55,265—7.5 percent less than the peak and 3.7 percent lower than in 2011.

As the number of table games has expanded, the play per table has declined, implying that the amount of money being spent by gamblers at table games seems to be spread even thinner as the number of casinos, and table games, across the state increases. 

Other forms of gaming

When Pennsylvania passed gaming legislation in 2004 only neighboring New Jersey, West Virginia and some Native American properties in New York had legalized gaming.  Upon Pennsylvania passing slots legislation, West Virginia countered with legalizing table games to which Pennsylvania countered with table games legislation of its own.  Ohio and Maryland also legalized gaming in their states, both slots and tables, while New Jersey passed an internet gaming law.  A gaming arms race was underway.

Pennsylvania countered New Jersey with an internet gaming law of its own and also legalized fantasy sports contests, video gaming terminals at truck stops and sports wagering (Policy Brief Vol. 20, No. 7). 

While casino-based slot machines still hold the lead in total revenue generated ($203.3 million of $425.9 million), in October it accounted for 48 percent of total gaming revenue.  However, this is likely to fall as internet gaming increases in popularity.  There are three internet gaming options:  slots, tables and poker.  Internet gaming in Pennsylvania can only be done by those physically within Pennsylvania’s borders with casinos located in the commonwealth.

Internet slot gaming is taxed at the same as the physical slot machines (54 percent) but the allocation is different. Instead of 34 percent going to the property tax relief fund, only 65 percent of that 34 percent is given to the property tax relief fund.  The remainder goes to the general fund.  In October, total revenue from internet slot play was the third-highest total behind physical slot machines and table games.  At $70.7 million it accounted for about 17 percent of all gaming revenues. 

Internet table game revenues are taxed at the same rate as the physical table games and have the same allocations.  They were the fourth-largest revenue generator ($29.3 million) and account for 7 percent of all gaming revenues.  Internet poker rounds out the three at $2.9 million and is just under 1 percent of all gaming revenues in October. 

In total, internet gaming accounts for over 24 percent of total gaming revenues and tops physical table games ($89.1 million or 21 percent of the total) as the second-leading form of gaming in Pennsylvania.  Its popularity may only be increasing due to its convenience.  It will be worth tracking going forward.  But, more importantly, it will be interesting to track the amount of money it contributes to the school property tax relief fund, the originally stated primary reason we have gaming in Pennsylvania.

Conclusion

Another reason gaming legislation passed was to keep Pennsylvanians from taking their disposable income across state lines to gamble and to entice those from other states to gamble here.  As nearly all bordering states having gaming, the percentage of out-of-state gamblers has undoubtedly fallen since the first casinos opened in Pennsylvania in 2006.  Most of the gaming revenue comes from Pennsylvanians. 

And that is the most concerning part.  As gaming options have increased, they have drawn more Pennsylvanians’ disposable income away from other entertainment options such as movies, theaters, etc.  It also offers another gaming alternative to the state Lottery where the proceeds benefit senior citizen programs. 

Pennsylvania should not be looking to the gaming industry to sustain its economy or fill tax coffers.  The expansion of gaming options has brought gambling to a wider swath of Pennsylvanians and the social consequences have yet to be fully understood.

Gaming revenues are rebounding

Summary: As happened to most industries, Pennsylvania’s casinos took a big hit during the pandemic.  But the losses were not as heavy as they could have been thanks to the advent of internet gaming, which cushioned the blow created by mandated casino closings. As COVID vaccinations become more prevalent, people are returning to the casinos and revenues, and gaming tax dollars, are beginning to rebound.

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Gaming revenues in Pennsylvania have become an important source of government funding.  From property tax relief and contributions to general fund revenue to county and municipal host government payments, state and local governments are reliant on gaming.  In 2020 the pandemic closed casinos for nearly three full months (part of March, April, May and most of December) and restricted patronage for most of the year.  Total gaming revenue for the year fell from $3.41 billion in 2019 to $2.65 billion (22.2 percent), the lowest annual total since the first full year of table games play a decade ago ($2.89 billion in 2011). 

The Allegheny Institute has been documenting gaming revenues since the legislation to introduce slots gaming was ratified in 2004 (Vol. 4, No. 28) through the beginning of table games in 2009 and the latest addition of internet gaming, sports wagering, video gaming terminals and fantasy sports contests within the last few years (Vol. 20, No. 7) and how each option is taxed.

Revenues have continued to rise over the years in part because of the expansion of gaming options and the increase in the number of casinos in operation. 

The data for this Brief comes from the Pennsylvania Gaming Control Board.  This analysis covers the period from 2015 through April 2021, the most recent data available. 

Slot machines

In 2015 the 12 casinos operating within the commonwealth brought in $2.365 billion dollars in gross terminal revenue (GTR).  Over the period prior to the pandemic in 2020 GTR was relatively stable, ranging from $2.336 billion (2017) to a high of $2.369 billion (2018). GTR is taxed at a total rate of 54 percent—34 percent for property tax relief; a 2 percent assessment for the local share (with an additional 2 percent for the two smaller resort casinos); a 6 percent rate is added for economic development and tourism fund with the remainder allocated to the racehorse development fund. 

In 2020 the governor shut down casinos halfway through March, all of April and May and then again for most of December.  When they were open, they did so at dramatically reduced patronage levels.  However, the first new mini casino opened in Westmoreland County in November, bringing the number of casinos in operation to 13.  The statewide GTR for 2020 came in at $1.355 billion, more than $1 billion lower than what it had been over the last few years. 

In 2021 there appears to be a rebound to statewide GTR.  First, another mini casino in Philadelphia opened bringing the total to 14.  Secondly, as the pandemic began to wane as vaccinations increased, more players returned to the casinos. 

The average monthly GTR for January, from 2015 through 2019, was $180.74 million.  In January 2021, it was $140.74 million—$40 million below the four-year average.  By April, the difference between 2021 and the four-year average for the month closed dramatically to just over $4 million ($205.43 million vs. $201.39 million).  Through the first four months of 2021 statewide GTR is on pace to reach $2.061 billion in 2021—87 percent of the average annual total for the 2015 through 2019 period.  Granted this is with 14 casinos instead of 12. 

It is also worth noting that the number of slot machines available has decreased despite the addition of the two new mini casinos.  In 2015 there were an average of 26,300 slot machines in operation each month.  That dipped a bit by 2019 to 24,700—a decline of 6 percent.  In 2020 that number declined another 25 percent to 18,500.  Thus far in 2021 there has been a small bump back to 19,300. 

On a revenue per machine basis, in 2015 the average monthly GTR was $7,500.  It steadily grew to $7,950 by 2019 before falling to $7,200 in 2020.  However, in 2021 that number has jumped to $8,860 per machine owing in part to more intense play, both March and April had per machine play over $10,000 (the highest amount recorded), as patrons streamed back to the casinos. 

Table games

Tax money from table games revenue goes into the state’s general fund (12 percent) with another 2 percent going to the local share fund.  The only exception is for fully automated table games which are taxed at 34 percent, but there are far fewer of them. 

From 2015 through 2019, statewide table game revenue from all 12 casinos had been on an upswing from $808.14 million in 2015 to $903.59 million in 2019 before dropping 44 percent in 2020 ($504.31 million).  Through four months in 2021, table games revenue is on pace to reach $772.28 million—89 percent of the 2015-19’s average amount. 

In fact, it may be the case that the annual gap will close even more.  As with the slots’ monthly revenues through the first four months, the revenue difference between each month for table games in 2021 and the monthly average from 2015-19, not only got smaller, but surpassed the average in April.  January 2021 brought in $50.83 million while the four-year average came in at $71.03 million—a more than $20 million difference.  By March that gap fell to just $6 million.  In April, the amount was $4 million greater than the 2015-19 average ($77.84 million vs. $73.71 million).

The number of table games available increased steadily from 2015 to 2019 rising from 1,130 to 1,276 and only fell back a bit to 1,171 after the pandemic started.  In 2021 the average number of monthly table games is up significantly to 1,370.  On a per table basis, the amount collected in 2021 has been increasing each month, but the monthly average of $46,876 is still below the monthly average from 2015-2019 which ranged from $57,460 (2018) to $59,737 (2017). 

Other forms of gaming

The other gaming options available to Pennsylvania gamblers are internet slots and table games (iGaming), each taxed at the same rate as its in-person counterpart (54 and 34 percent, respectively); video gaming terminals (VGT) at truck stops (taxed at 52 percent); fantasy sports contests (taxed at 15 percent) and sports wagering (taxed at 36 percent).  Sports wagering and fantasy sports contests began in 2018 while the others began in 2019. (The allocation of tax revenues can be found in Policy Brief Vol. 20, No. 7.)

iGaming debuted in mid-2019 and brought in $33.6 million in six months, an estimated $67.2 million annual rate. In 2020, the first full year, revenue rocketed to $565.8 million, largely thanks to the pandemic.  Thus far in 2021, it has brought in $346.6 million in total revenue and is on pace to reach $1.045 billion, surpassing the amount from in-casino table games. 

Sports wagering is the next largest category.  Wagering on sports brought in $84.1 million in its first full year (2019) and then more than doubled to $189.7 million in 2020 despite many sports leagues being shut down or having modified seasons due to the pandemic.  Thus far in 2021, with normality returning to sports, sports wagering has already reaped $106 million in four months and is on pace to reach $318 million by the end of the year. 

In all, these four new forms of gaming’s share of total gaming revenue increased from just 4 percent of total gaming revenues to 30 percent in 2020 and are likely to be one-third of all gaming revenues in 2021 (33.5 percent).  Whether or not they will continue to climb is a matter of speculation. As the coronavirus becomes less and less of a factor for in-person visits to casinos, they might enjoy a bit of resurgence in play relative to online activities.

It is probably too hard to tell what will happen as these online options are only a few years old and were boosted by the pandemic.  The convenience of gaming from home may be too hard to resist.  Or are people waiting to go back to the casinos?  Sports wagering, fantasy sports and VGTs are more likely determined by economic factors and disposable income.  It will likely be a few more years before the answer is known. 

But is the growth of gaming in Pennsylvania a good thing?  As noted above, nearly all of the commonwealth’s neighbors have legalized gaming (Delaware, Maryland, New Jersey, Ohio and West Virginia).  The implication is that a high percentage of gamblers are Pennsylvanians and not from out-of-state.  Online gaming can only be done by Pennsylvania residents to Pennsylvania registered casinos or companies.  Clearly, a dollar spent on gaming cannot be spent on other activities—either leisure or necessities.  That money goes to the state in taxes or to the casinos’ coffers as optional uses of discretionary income.

Should the government be this heavily dependent on gaming as a source of tax revenue?  The pandemic shows what can happen when the activity is impacted.  This time the federal government flooded the economy with stimulus money, direct government subsidies and supplemented unemployment compensation.  The drop in gaming revenue in 2020 was only 22 percent, in large part to the jump in online gambling revenue.  It could have been much larger.  The loss of tax revenues in general was likely made up by the federal government.   

What happens when the economy has a serious downturn, the discretionary spending ebbs and the federal government is unable to provide a bailout?  Politicians may be running out of ways to expand gaming options. What happens as Pennsylvania continues to lag much of the country in economic growth and jobs? Will the federal government always be able to provide billions of bailout dollars to the state?

Gaming as a recreational outlet must be kept in perspective.  Pennsylvania should not count on the gaming industry to sustain its economy or keep its tax coffers full. And, certainly, it cannot afford to ignore the social ills and costs that can accompany gambling addiction.

Gaming options expand in Pennsylvania

Summary: Gaming revenues grew in 2019.  But it was due more to the expansion of gaming options than growth to the existing system. Sports wagering, fantasy contests, internet gaming and, soon, mini-casinos should continue the trend.  But is the commonwealth’s reliance on tax revenues a sure thing? Will gaming boost the economy?

_______________________________________________________________________

At the conclusion of 2019, the state Gaming Control Board reported that total gaming revenues were up by 4.5 percent over 2018’s tally.  The revenue gain did not reflect an increase in the number of people playing slot machines, which debuted in 2006, or even table games (2010); it was primarily due to the expansion of gaming options.  In 2019 internet gaming and video gaming terminals debuted while retail and internet sports wagering and fantasy sports contests had their first full year.  With mini-casinos getting ready to open soon, and a full year of operation for last year’s newcomers, 2020 gaming revenue is likely to top 2019.

Slot machines

Statewide, the 12 casinos in operation realized $2.363 billion in gross terminal revenues (GTR) from slot machines in 2019—a slight dip of $6.8 million (-0.3 percent) from the previous year (all data is calendar year).  The high-water mark for GTR occurred in 2012 ($2.471 billion) from 11 casinos (the resort casino at Valley Forge opened in March 2012 while the one at Nemacolin opened in July 2013).   

The monthly average number of slot machines in operation has declined slightly over the years.  In 2012 there were 26,550 machines available on average per month across the state.  By 2019 that number had fallen to 24,722—a drop of 7 percent.  It is likely that space previously used for slot machines is now being used by table games or areas for sports betting—which is not a surprise given that slot machines are taxed at a higher rate than those options.   

Nonetheless, Pennsylvania has a lot riding on the performance of slot machines.  As noted in earlier Policy Briefs (most recently in Vol. 19, No. 15), slot machine GTR is taxed very heavily at 54 percent.  There is a 34 percent assessment for property tax relief;  a 2 percent assessment for the local share (with an additional 2 percent for the two smaller resort casinos); a 6 percent rate is added on for the economic development and tourism fund with the remainder allocated to the racehorse development fund. 

It is very interesting that $12.4 million per year of the economic and tourism fund is being allocated in perpetuity to Pittsburgh International Airport.  Reportedly the airport will use some of that money to help pay for the construction of a new terminal.   

Also, in his fiscal 2021 budget address, the governor is proposing to divert $204 million from the racehorse development fund to start a scholarship fund for students attending the 14 universities of Pennsylvania’s State System of Higher Education. The proposal is meeting predictable resistance from the racehorse industry.   

Table games

Tax revenue from slot machine GTR does not go into the state’s general fund budget.  But tax revenue from other gaming sources (table games, etc.) does.  The total tax rate on table games is 14 percent. A 12 percent rate is assigned to the state’s general fund and another 2 percent goes to fund the local share.  The only exception is for fully automated table games, which are taxed at 34 percent but there are far fewer of them. 

Table games were introduced in 2010 and the total revenues statewide have been on a fairly consistent growth path ever since (except a small dip from of 1.3 percent from 2017 to 2018).  In 2019 revenue from table games reached $903.6 million, $24.8 million (2.8 percent) higher than in 2018 and established a new high-water mark for the category.   

The average number of table games available per month statewide in 2019 was 1,275, up slightly from the 1,234 in 2018.   

Bear in mind that the increase in total table games revenue accounts for only 20 percent of the revenue increase from all gaming options ($24.8 million of $146.1 million) 

New forms of gaming

Two new forms of gaming were made available to the public in 2019 while two others had their first full years.   

Pennsylvania gamblers were able to play slots/table games on the internet beginning in July 2019.  Internet slot games are taxed at 54 percent, the same rate as traditional slots.  The allocation of the tax is a bit different:  34 percent to the state, 13 percent to the Commonwealth Financing Authority (county grants) and 7 percent for the local share.  The economic development and tourism fund and the racehorse development fund do not receive money from internet slots.  Funds from the state share of the tax are split between property tax relief (65 percent) and the state treasury.  Internet table games are taxed at the same rate as casino-based table games, 14 percent, with the same allocations.     

In just six months of 2019, internet gaming brought in $33.6 million in total revenues—$20.9 million from internet slots and $12.6 million from internet table games. 

Video gaming terminals opened at 20 truck stops across the commonwealth in August 2019.  A total of 100 machines collected $2.3 million in revenues over the last few months of 2019.  They are taxed at a rate of 52 percent—a 42 percent assessment going to the state’s general fund with a small portion of that going to a compulsive and problem gambling treatment fund and a 10 percent assessment to the local share.   

Fantasy gaming began in May 2018.  It is a process where a gamer selects players (typically football) to form a team that will compete (statistically) against other gamers’ teams.  This gaming avenue is taxed at a rate of 15 percent which goes to the state’s general fund.   

In just eight months fantasy gaming brought in $15.3 million in revenues in 2018.  For the full calendar year of 2019 fantasy gaming brought in $25.9 million, an increase of 69 percent over 2018.   

The final form of gaming, and the biggest of the new additions in Pennsylvania, is sports wagering.  Calendar 2019 represented the first full year of sports wagering in the commonwealth.  It is taxed at a rate of 36 percent—34 percent to the state’s general fund and 2 percent to the local share.   

Total sports wagering revenues in 2019 were $84.1 million (51.1 percent of that was wagered online, while the rest was wagered in person).  Sports wagering in 2018 consists of just November and December.  The total wagering revenues from these two months was $2.5 million.   

It is very likely that there will be substantial growth in Pennsylvania’s gaming industry in at least 2020.  First of all, the industry will grow with the addition of the new mini-casinos which should debut soon and some of these options such as video gaming terminals and internet based gaming have not yet had a full calendar year of operation.   

Gaming and the economy

But more importantly the national economic growth is putting more discretionary funds into people’s pockets and gaming is one form of recreation available in Pennsylvania. But is this a good thing?  Should the government be so dependent upon gaming as a source of tax revenue?   

Clearly, a dollar spent on one activity cannot be spent on another. Money spent on gaming comes at the cost of other options, most likely other leisure activities.     

According to Bureau of Labor Statistics’ (BLS) data, Pennsylvania’s “amusements, gambling and recreation” sector jobs stood at 58,500 in December 2019. In December 2018 that number was 62,200—a year-over-year loss of 3,700 jobs. The current job count stands 10 percent above 2009’s 52,400. In comparison, national employment in the “amusements, gambling and recreation” sector climbed 30 percent. Note that data for the gambling sector itself are not available at the state level. 

However, at the national level, jobs data are available for the gambling industries.  In December 2009 there were 126,600 jobs in the gambling industry. The count rose to 132,300 (4.5 percent) in 2013 before dropping 13 percent by December 2019.  Over the 10 years 2009 to 2019 the nation’s gambling jobs fell by 11,200 or 9 percent. Furthermore, nationally casino employment is down 5.7 percent over the last 10 years and by 14.5 percent since the peak of 2013.  Is this due to automation and the advent of alternative online gaming? Or could it be that the gambling industry has peaked and is in decline?  At this juncture, it seems unlikely that gaming will have much of an impact on Pennsylvania’s job count in the years to come.  

In 2009, employees in gambling industries accounted for 10 percent of the jobs in the “amusements, gambling and recreation” sector.  By 2019, the gambling share had fallen to 7 percent.  While Pennsylvania’s gambling share of “amusement, gambling and recreation” employment is not provided by the BLS, it seems reasonable to assume it is in the 7 to 10 percent range. And, if it is following the national trend, the share is declining.

As for the tax revenues that policy makers are more than happy to collect, what happens when the economy has a downturn and the discretionary spending ebbs?  How secure are these revenue streams?  Politicians may be running out of ways to expand gaming in the commonwealth.   

Gaming as a recreational outlet must be kept in perspective.  Pennsylvania should not look to the gaming industry to sustain its economy or keep its tax coffers full, not to mention the social ills and costs that can accompany gambling addiction or the impact on lottery sales.